Dotty Documentation


Restrictions to Implicit Conversions

Edit this page on GitHub

Previously, an implicit value of type Function1, or any of its subtypes could be used as an implicit conversion. That is, the following code would compile even though it probably masks a type error:

implicit val m: Map[String, Int] = Map(1 -> "abc")

val x: String = 1  // scalac: assigns "abc" to x
                   // Dotty: type error

By contrast, Dotty only considers methods as implicit conversions, so the Map value m above would not qualify as a conversion from String to Int.

To be able to express implicit conversions passed as parameters, Dotty introduces a new type

abstract class ImplicitConverter[-T, +U] extends Function1[T, U]

Implicit values of type ImplicitConverter[A, B] do qualify as implicit conversions. It is as if there was a global implicit conversion method

def convert[A, B](x: A)(implicit converter: ImplicitConverter[A, B]): B =

(In reality the Dotty compiler simulates the behavior of this method directly in its type checking because this turns out to be more efficient).

In summary, previous code using implicit conversion parameters such as

def useConversion(implicit f: A => B) = {
  val y: A = ...
  val x: B = a    // error under Dotty

is no longer legal and has to be rewritten to

def useConversion(implicit f: ImplicitConverter[A, B]) = {
  val y: A = ...
  val x: B = y    // OK


For more info, see PR #2065.